Adversarial questions are necessary for a fair trial, opinion argues
The writer cites rape cases where defence cross-examination lasted eight days.
A defence barrister writing in Ireland and the UK argues that adversarial questioning is essential to the criminal justice system, even in rape cases.
The opinion piece says defence counsel can suspect a client is guilty but cannot knowingly mislead the court, and that defendants are entitled to robust advocacy. It points to bar conduct codes in Ireland and in England and Wales requiring barristers to promote a client’s best interests using proper, lawful means.
Because the system is adversarial, counsel must put the client’s case to witnesses so they can answer it. In rape trials, the writer says this can lead to questioning about consent and surrounding circumstances, with limits on questioning about clothing and previous sexual history.
The article references an Irish rugby-related case in 2018 in which the complainant alleged rape spent eight days in the witness box and was cross-examined by four sets of barristers, all men. It also notes that one defence asked the jury to consider that the complainant was lying and that the sex was consensual, while the jury ultimately returned not guilty verdicts on all charges.
The writer also discusses the public backlash after a convicted sex offender’s defence counsel was criticised for arguments made during closing submissions, and describes criticism from political figures and a police commissioner who said the approach risked victim blaming.
The piece is published as an opinion item and does not report any new investigation, arrest, charge or sentencing.
ADVERTISEMENT
Source:
TheJournal.ie