Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe into NHS Grampian deaths
A leaked 2022 review flagged 19 avoidable deaths from 45 liver and pancreatic cases at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
A consultant surgeon has called for a corporate homicide investigation into claims of avoidable deaths among NHS Grampian patients over many years.
The surgeon, who still works at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, says he has raised concerns for a decade, including with government ministers and police, but was ignored.
He leaked an unpublished expert review from 2022 which examined liver and pancreatic surgery at the Aberdeen hospital for patients treated between 2015 and 2021.
The review focused on 45 patients and found 31 died. It said 19 of the deaths were avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention.
His allegations include patients who bled to death in the operating theatre, and the experts described blood losses in both liver and pancreatic procedures as unacceptably high.
The leaked 2022 report said mortality rates for major liver resections at NHS Grampian were far above what would be expected. Between 2017 and 2020, it reported a 12% death rate after 30 days and 18% after 90 days after major liver resections, compared with an expected rate of 2.2%.
In liver surgery, the report criticised decision-making it described as sometimes overly aggressive, with operations proceeding even when disease was thought to be inoperable.
For pancreatic surgery, the experts said patients were regularly rushed into theatre without adequate planning or consideration of non-surgical alternatives. They also pointed to a lack of leadership and no clear standards for planning before operations.
A second external expert report, published earlier this year, echoed similar themes, describing long-standing and recurrent problems and saying structural changes had not been made despite attempts to improve outcomes.
The surgeon said he formally reported serious concerns about dozens of avoidable deaths in 2021. In 2024, he reported 20 cases from the previous decade to police, but no charges have been brought.
The latest calls come as NHS Grampian faces scrutiny after a recent report found major deficiencies across the region and said failures to learn from mistakes had caused repeated and avoidable harm to patients.
The board has yet to comment on the surgeon’s latest public claims.
ADVERTISEMENT
Source:
BBC News