Estonia ruling on confiscation powers for illegal e-scooters
A police traffic official compares fast scooters to banned contraband, but a legal challenge says scooter possession is not illegal.
Estonia’s debate over e-scooter enforcement is reigniting after a traffic policing official drew a controversial comparison between illegal speed and prohibited contraband.
In the discussion, police warned about young riders using powerful scooters with speed limiters removed and riding in traffic despite legal rules. The police traffic supervision unit chief said scooters exceeding legal speed limits should be treated like weapons, narcotics and contraband cigarettes, whose possession or handling is prohibited in Estonia.
But legal arguments presented in the article say the comparison is inappropriate, because possessing a scooter is not illegal. Using a noncompliant scooter is prohibited only in public traffic.
The article focuses on confiscation powers, describing confiscation as a far-reaching restriction on property rights protected by the constitution. It also says Estonia’s Supreme Court has required justification for confiscating an instrument used to commit an offense, including the likelihood of similar violations and whether less severe measures have been tried and failed.
While it argues police should be able to remove a noncompliant vehicle from traffic, it questions whether police should permanently deprive someone of property without prior judicial review. Police can already seize a scooter from its user, store it, process the violation, and seek a court order to confiscate it.
It adds that courts have not granted police requests in earlier cases, with proportionality and private property protections likely among the factors, and that some applications may not have been sufficiently justified.
To bring repeated scooter violations under control without relying on permanent confiscation by the executive, the article proposes six measures: higher fines, a points system affecting scooter permits and future eligibility for a driver’s license, community service, stronger involvement of parents, returning scooters only after they are brought into compliance, and harsher penalties for repeat offenses, including the existing option to ask a court for confiscation.
The latest confirmed status described is that confiscation requests through courts have not been granted in past cases, while enforcement and legal debate continue.
ADVERTISEMENT
Source:
ERR News